Diamond Earrings

Sell Diamond Earrings

Diamond earrings are often given as a thoughtful and timeless gift. Maybe you received them for a special occasion like a birthday, anniversary, or holiday, or simply as a thoughtful gesture. Or maybe you bought them for yourself, or received a pair of diamond earrings in an inheritance. Whatever the reason, if these pieces of jewelry don’t bring you joy, selling them is probably a great idea.

You can use the cash to buy yourself new jewelry, pay bills, or for something else you enjoy instead.

Diamond Earrings

The price we pay for diamond earrings depends on a number of factors. First and foremost, the value of the diamond(s). For more information, check out Diamond Karma’s article on how Diamonds are priced using the 4 C’s (the size of the diamond, the cut, the clarity, and the color).
The quoting process can be done much quicker and with more confidence if your earrings contain certified diamonds. Certificates like AGS, EGL, GIA (the most popular), HRD, or IGI provide verified information about the 4 C’s, allowing for much quicker estimates rather than having to inspect the diamond.
If you have no documentation, it is still possible for us to buy your diamonds. Once it is sent to our facility, your diamonds will be inspected and appraised by a professional as part of the process in making an offer for your earrings and other jewelry.

We do not purchase diamonds that:

  • Have been clarity enhanced
  • Have been color treated
  • Have been laser drilled
  • Have clarity of I1, I2, I3, or SI3
  • Have strong fluorescence
  • Have poor cuts

If your earrings have other precious metals or gemstones in them, such as silver or diamonds, our team of professionals will estimate the price of each section and pay you appropriately for each one. We’ll clearly explain how your diamonds and jewelry are priced and give you a no-obligation offer to purchase your jewelry.

The accurate value of your diamond earrings can only be determined after it has been expected by a professional to verify its quality, weight, and purity. If you’d like a free appraisal and offer for your gold, diamond, and other jewelry, fill out our form on the left to print your free label or request a free cash for gold mailer pack.

Calculating the Value of Diamond Earrings

The actual value of your diamond earrings are determined by adding the value of the non-diamond component with the value of any diamonds or gemstones. Which makes sense, of course. We’re generally purchasing your unwanted diamond jewelry for its parts, rather than for the piece as a whole. In some rare cases, we are able to offer a price above just the value of the gold and diamonds, like if there is a premium brand name attached to the piece.

Diamond Karma’s diamond value calculator is a good place to start if you’d like a rough valuation of your diamond (assuming you have a certification or are confident in the grading of each of the 4 C’s). But as mentioned above, the 4 C’s essentially determine the value of the diamond itself.


Clarity refers to the presence of internal flaws (inclusions) and external blemishes in a diamond. Diamonds are graded on a scale ranging from Flawless (no inclusions or blemishes visible under 10x magnification) to Included (inclusions and/or blemishes visible to the naked eye). Diamonds with fewer inclusions and blemishes are more valuable.

If there are NO inclusions, that’s a sign that the diamond is lab grown. While lab grown diamonds look amazing and can be a good ethical choice, it unfortunately significantly reduces their resale value. At Cash for Gold Mailer, we rarely buy lab-grown diamonds.

Carats (Weight)

Carat is a unit of measurement for diamonds. One carat is equivalent to 200 milligrams. Larger diamonds generally command higher prices, but other factors such as cut, color, and clarity also play a significant role in determining the overall value.


The color grade of a diamond is a measure of how colorless or “white” it is. The GIA grades diamonds on a scale from D (colorless) to Z (light yellow or brown). The less color a diamond has, the more valuable it is considered to be.


The cut of a diamond refers to how well the diamond has been shaped and faceted. It is not about the shape (round, princess, etc.) but rather the quality of the cut, which influences how well the diamond reflects light. A well-cut diamond will sparkle more, making it more valuable.

Evaluating the value of gold and other pieces

If you’d like to calculate the value of the gold, you’ll want to learn how to determine the amount of gold in your jewelry. The value of the gold in your earrings depends on the price of gold, weight, and purity of the gold.

The calculation would be very similar if the diamond is primarily made out of another metal, such as platinum (more valuable) or silver (less valuable).

Get a Free Quote

The value of diamond earrings can vary a lot depending on all these factors. Some are worth tens of thousands of dollars, while many times small diamonds don’t have substantial value. That said, small diamonds with exceptional cut, clarity, and colors can be worth more than you think!

Once the pricing factors are calculated on your diamond earrings, we can determine how much your diamond is worth. At Cash for Gold Mailer, we operate as efficiently as possible and work with the lowest margins in the industry. That’s why we guarantee the best offer, local or online, for your gold, diamonds, and valuables.

Ready to get started? Request a free pack today!

Get Your

By submitting your information you agree to our
Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions.